Talk:Shuichi Kagaya/@comment-46304361-20200709081101/@comment-24053170-20200713030845

Let me make on detail clear that you seem to have missed.

The Alien cannot retcon Honoka meeting him, because she was the very first person to find a coin.

If the Alien retconned that, then the series would never have happened and it would cause a Paradox.

The encounter with Honoka is what led to the entire plot of the story.

If you remove Honoka from the equation, the Alien is right back to square one. Since he cannot gather any coins and cannot bestow anyone any abilities/wishes, because Honoka was the one that suggested the whole Coin game and wishes in the first place.

I'm not being rude. I'm simply pointing out the flaws in your plan and logic.

You can't change the past in this story.

I understand your viewpoint because you have only seen the anime. But the anime already explained all of this as well.

The Alien even said that honoka was the first person to find one of the coins, and that no one else found one before her.

So if you retcon Honoka meeting the Alien, how can he claim to still have any of the other Coins? Because no one else would bother to find them if it wasn't for the wishes he granted.

He would still be stuck on earth, and he wouldn't have any of the coins.

Its a catch-22.