Talk:Elena Aoki/@comment-46304361-20200709081502/@comment-24053170-20200713013833

Sorry to poor water on your theory, but Shuichi is very much alive.

The Shuichi you see in the show is the real shuichi and it always has been.

Elena simply altered his memories so he wouldn't have to worry about the deaths of Aiko and Honoka.

In her own way, Elena was trying to protect Shuichi.

Elena is not a wisher. As wishes can only be made if you collect a hundred coins. And Kaito is currently the only person in the show to have done so.

Your theory about shuichi doesn't have any actual backing, since the manga has already proven that Shuichi is alive and always has been.

Only Aiko and Honoka died. Shuichi's memory block was caused by Elena.

If you read the manga you would know that everyone of your theories has been proven false.